In 1881, Charles Darwin penned a etter expressing a troubling doubt: "But then with me the horrid doubt always arises whether the convictions of man's mind, which has been developed from the mind of the lower animals, are of any value or at all trustworthy. Would anyone trust in the convictions of a monkey's mind, if there are any convictions in such a mind?"
Darwin’s Doubt: if human beings evolved from simpler, non-rational life forms, and if our mental faculties are products of random, non-rational physical processes, can we trust our minds to reason rationally? Are our convictions mere survival mechanisms, or can they access truth?
The human mind is extraordinary, outshining all other creatures with its unparalleled cognitive abilities. It allows us to explore abstract concepts, uncover universal truths, and comprehend the universe’s vast complexities. Yet, these capabilities often appear to surpass what is strictly necessary for survival. Natural selection, by its nature, prioritizes survival value over truth value; a belief need not be true to ensure survival—it need only work.
Consider a simple analogy: John and Mark are asked to run blindfolded across a busy highway. John’s cognitive faculties are functioning perfectly, so he reasons that the act would be dangerous and refuses. Mark, however, has impaired reasoning and falsely believes there is no traffic—but also believes his feet are glued to the ground, so he doesn’t run either. Both survive, yet only John’s reasoning was based on truth. This example illustrates how survival is not necessarily contingent on truth but can result from flawed reasoning or chance.
Beyond the marvel of the human mind lies another mystery: the rationality of the universe itself. If everything is the product of blind, random processes, how can we account for a universe governed by consistent laws and mathematical coherence? Albert Einstein once remarked, “What is inconceivable about the universe is that it is at all conceivable.” This rational order—this structured, law-abiding cosmos—presents a profound challenge to the notion of an inherently chaotic, purposeless origin.
Order does not arise from disorder, just as rationality does not spring from non-rationality. To believe otherwise is akin to expecting a random scattering of Scrabble tiles to form a coherent sentence. Rationality demands an explanation beyond randomness, for neither the mind’s capacity for reason nor the universe’s rational structure can be adequately reduced to chance.
Science itself hinges on two foundational requirements: a rational mind and a rational universe. The absence of either would render scientific inquiry impossible. These two elements work together like a lock and key—the rational mind being the key capable of unlocking the rational universe. But how did these two interdependent phenomena come to exist in perfect harmony? Random chance alone fails to provide a satisfying explanation. Keys do not fit locks by accident; they are designed to fit.
This harmony suggests intentionality, pointing to the existence of an All-Knowing, All-Wise Creator. Rationality cannot emerge from non-rationality, and the trust we place in our cognitive faculties must stem from a source of ultimate reason. God’s existence not only makes sense of the rational mind and universe but also provides a framework for understanding their purpose.
The Quran rarely attempts to prove God’s existence—it assumes it as self-evident. Instead, it invites humanity to move beyond acknowledgment of His existence to recognition of His worthiness of worship. One way the Quran does this is by directing our attention to creation itself. Within the natural world lie signs of His majesty, power, and wisdom, prompting reflection and leading us to affirm His greatness.
As the Quran states: "Indeed, in the creation of the heavens and the earth and the alternation of the night and the day are signs for those of understanding." (Quran 3:190)
The purpose of the rational mind and the rational universe becomes clear when viewed through this lens. Both were given to us so that we may reflect on creation, recognize the Creator, and fulfill our ultimate purpose: to worship Him. The One who made everything and gave us everything deserves our gratitude and devotion. Rationality itself is a sign of His wisdom, inviting us to ponder, understand, and ultimately, to worship.
Leave a Comment